Now after they had left, an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and said, “Get up, take the child and his mother, and flee to Egypt, and remain there until I tell you; for Herod is about to search for the child, to destroy him.” Then Joseph got up, took the child and his mother by night, and went to Egypt, and remained there until the death of Herod. This was to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet, “Out of Egypt I have called my son.” When Herod saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, he was infuriated, and he sent and killed all the children in and around Bethlehem who were two years old or under, according to the time that he had learned from the wise men. Then was fulfilled what had been spoken through the prophet Jeremiah: “A voice was heard in Ramah, wailing and loud lamentation, Rachel weeping for her children; she refused to be consoled, because they are no more.” (Matthew 2:13-18 NRSV)
It was such a cute scene. Who can resist a baby wrapped in swaddling clothes. Angels singing to him, shepherds in a field keeping watch over their flocks by night. Wise men from the east bringing him gifts of Gold, Frankincense, and Myrrh and presenting their gifts at the foot of the manger. Mary gazing at her infant while Joseph kneels tenderly looking at her. The flicker of the campfire against the walls. All were snuggly warm, happy and content.
And then Matthew ruins this cute scene with this story. If it is such a cute scene why does Matthew have to go and ruin it with a story of this cute family having to run for their lives and ruin it even further by telling a story of the massacre of children? Why would he do such a thing?
I think it is because we are more influenced by the Christmas plays held in churches during this season and the nativity scenes we place on our coffee tables.
Matthew places this text in his Gospel precisely to turn our attention away from cute. I think he was concerned that we would so focus on the cute of Christmas that we would sterilize it from the reality of the scene.
You see there was little that was cute about the whole birth story.
Mary, a virgin, is pregnant and her story is that God has come to her and impregnated her. Not a cute story for sure, she probably could have come up with something better than that.
The man to whom Mary is engaged decides to put her away quietly until he too is visited by an angel. Still he should have sent her away because if she stays there he has the legal right to have her stoned to death.
The Emperor Augustus orders a census be taken. He could probably care less how many people are under his rule he just wants to know how many people he can tax. All of us know that taxes are not cute.
Mary, with her very large belly, gets on the back of a donkey to make the journey with Joseph. On the way the labor pains start. Joseph doesn’t know nothing about birthin no babies continues to push on to his ancestral home of Bethlehem.
They get there late because Mary has slowed them down so much and they find that all the hotels are full. Nothing cute about that. Someone tells them that they can stay in a cattle barn and since they have no choice and Mary’s labor pains are getting closer and closer together, they decide it will have to do. They probably had to shovel some animal leavings out the door and they lay a fresh layer of straw on the floor, then lay Mary on the straw to give birth to her child. There is no mention of a midwife in any of the stories so Mary and Joseph, mostly Mary, have to give birth on straw, on the floor of a cattle stall.
You older men are lucky. When your babies were born you got to sit in a nice sterile waiting room while your children were born. Us younger guys were “invited to watch.” Once you “watch” two things happen. You get to see your baby before your wife does, and two, you discover that it is a scene worthy of any of the best slasher movies shown at Halloween each year, there ain’t anything cute about it.
When our son was born we got to the hospital early in the morning, not sun peeking over the horizon in shades of reds and yellow as a new day bursts upon the night sky. I am talking dark morning. The dark morning that the only people on the road are the drunks trying to get home and the early morning radio disc jockeys going to work.
Garland General Hospital, Garland Texas, was our destination. When we got there they were just preparing to start moving equipment into a new OB/Gyn wing of the hospital. They had to go find a bed to put Kenda in, scrounge around for a monitor, and brought a metal “church” chair for me. Kenda was going to be the first to deliver a child in this new OB/Gyn wing of Garland Memorial Hospital. She was in labor, the pain was tremendous, she kept staring at me with eyes that looked nothing like the eyes of Mary in the Manger scene on the coffee table. They gave her an “epidural.” She went to sleep. I had to sit in a metal “church” chair, turning and squirming, while my dear wife was snoring. I wanted me one of them “epidural” thingies too.
But it was O.K. because Kenda would be the first to give birth in the brand new OB/Gyn wing of Garland Memorial Hospital in Garland Texas. Now how may people can say that.
About six hours or so into labor when “we” were progressing nicely, a woman came in who was about to have her seventh or eight child. The put her in the room across the hall. She said “Ouch” and squirted her child out. Now the one thing that had kept me going while my dear wife slept was gone and that metal “church” chair was even more uncomfortable than ever.
This was Mary’s first child. There was no “ouch” and it was over with. Mary had to endure hours of labor while Joseph looked for a pan to boil some water in. Then the baby came in a rush of liquid goo, everything under her is wet and bloody, and Joseph abandons his quest for a pan, dries the baby off, wraps him in dry cloth, and hands him to Mary. There is nothing cute here.
Then some shepherds show up. Shepherds staying out in the field had little time for personal hygiene. They were dirty and smelled like sheep, campfire smoke, and body odor, mixed. Not cute.
Then some wise men stop by Herod’s house asking if he knows anything about this “king” that is born? They don’t know, they are just following a star. He lies to them and tells them that when they find him to come back and tell him so that he too can go and worship this newborn king. Lying is never cute.
They bring their gifts to the foot of the manger. Gold, a gift for a king. Frankincense, a gift for a priest. Myrrh, a gift for one who was to die. Now that last part isn’t cute.
Herod learns he has been deceived and orders a massacre of children under a certain age. He will have no “king” born while he is king. Massacre’s are definitely not cute.
The early church didn’t want to remember the Christmas story as a “cute” story so on the 26th of December they remembered the Martyrdom of Saint Stephen. Then on the 28th they remembered the children lain by Herod.
I believe they did both those things for the same reason Matthew includes this text, they wanted to remember that it was not a “cute” event.
I believe that what Matthew does is supposed to remind us that Jesus was not born into a world of “cute” but into a dirty, nasty, hard birth, hard life, world. He does it to remind us that he was born into a world of superstition that was ruled by paranoid and ruthless kings.
I believe that Matthew included this text so we would be reminded that the Savior born in Bethlehem was born for the dirty, nasty, smelly, working man as well as the rich and elegant elite.
The nativity genealogy puts Mary in the lineage of Tamar, Rahab, Bathsheeba, and Ruth (yes, the one who snuck in to the rich Boaz’s tent at night while he was sleeping to seduce him). Jesus’ genealogy is not cute.
If you look at the story as it was we find little that was actually about the events so long ago that was cute.
I guess the closest to cute we have in the whole story is God giving up heaven for a cattle stall. God coming to earth so we can know him. God descending from on high to break into a dirty, troubled, not cute world.
Now that I think of it, that is not cute, it is a good gift from a loving God.